2005 lieu dit Malakoff Shiraz – 90-94 points
-By Robert M. Parker, Jr. - The Wine Advocate
 10/31/2005

2004 lieu dit Malakoff Shiraz – Excellent
-By Fred Koeppel - KoeppelonWine.com 
 5/20/2006

2004 lieu dit Malakoff Shiraz – 92 points
-By Harvey Steiman - Wine Spectator
 5/3/2006

2004 lieu dit Malakoff Shiraz - 90-92 points
-By Robert M. Parker, Jr. - The Wine Advocate
 10/31/2004

2004 Shiraz-Viognier – Excellent
-By Fred Koeppel - KoeppelonWine.com
 5/20/2006